Did Cleveland Peak Too Early?

I heard something on Against All Odds, that didn't seem quite right to me.

In September, Cleveland went on a 22-game winning streak. A Yankees fan on the podcast said Cleveland peaked too early. Me, being of sound mind and body, thought that winning 22 games in September is a good sign for winning say 12 out of 21 games in October.

So here we are. Cleveland vs New York.

My theory is Cleveland should win.
His theory is New York should win.

Let's see what happens.

Edit: Damnit, Cleveland peaked too early.