I can't embed it, so I'll just link to it.
You Don't See THAT Everyday Moments!
I went back to look at the Calcutta for the years where the Chiefs won the Super Bowl. I was curious if I ever owned them when they won it all.
2019
Some initial observations.
I never owned the Chiefs when they won.
I always owned the NFC Super Bowl opponent. (49ers, Eagles, 49ers)
In 2019, even though I didn't own the Champion, I still won the Calcutta, which is crazy.
Then I went back to look at the history over the last seven seasons:
NFL Calcutta
1962 — Len Dawson — Houston Oilers — Championship, W 20–17 OT
1966 — Len Dawson — Buffalo Bills — AFL Championship, W 31–7
1969 — Len Dawson — New York Jets — Divisional, W 13–6
1969 — Len Dawson — Oakland Raiders — AFL Championship, W 17–7
1969 — Len Dawson — Minnesota Vikings — Super Bowl IV, W 23–7
1991 — Steve DeBerg — Los Angeles Raiders — Wild Card, W 10–6
1993 — Joe Montana — Pittsburgh Steelers — Wild Card, W 27–24 OT
1993 — Joe Montana — Houston Oilers — Divisional, W 28–20
2015 — Alex Smith — Houston Texans — Divisional, W 30–0
2018 — Patrick Mahomes — Indianapolis Colts — Divisional, W 31–13
2019 — Patrick Mahomes — Houston Texans — Divisional, W 51–31
2019 — Patrick Mahomes — Tennessee Titans — AFC Championship, W 35–24
2019 — Patrick Mahomes — San Francisco 49ers — Super Bowl LIV, W 31–20
2020 — Patrick Mahomes — Cleveland Browns — Divisional, W 22–17
2020 — Patrick Mahomes — Buffalo Bills — AFC Championship, W 38–24
2021 — Patrick Mahomes — Pittsburgh Steelers — Wild Card, W 42–21
2021 — Patrick Mahomes — Buffalo Bills — Divisional, W 42–36 OT
2022 — Patrick Mahomes — Jacksonville Jaguars — Divisional, W 27–20
2022 — Patrick Mahomes — Cincinnati Bengals — AFC Championship, W 23–20
2022 — Patrick Mahomes — Philadelphia Eagles — Super Bowl LVII, W 38–35
2023 — Patrick Mahomes — Miami Dolphins — Wild Card, W 26–7
2023 — Patrick Mahomes — Buffalo Bills — Divisional, W 27–24
2023 — Patrick Mahomes — Baltimore Ravens — AFC Championship, W 17–10
2023 — Patrick Mahomes — San Francisco 49ers — Super Bowl LVIII, W 25–22 OT
2024 — Patrick Mahomes — Houston Texans — Divisional, W 23–14
2024 — Patrick Mahomes — Buffalo Bills — AFC Championship, W 32–29
So I keep a running ranked list of their movies combined.
So I created a system to weight those ratings and rankings.
100 pts for 5 stars, 90 for 4.5, 70 for 4, 50 for 3.5, 30 for 3. And then bonus points for ranked spots on the list.
I fed my last 7 NFL previews to ChatGPT and had it grade them.
Instead of trying to manufacture a numerical score, I think letter grades tell the story better.
Chiefs over Saints
Result: Champion correct (2/3)
Chiefs over Saints
Result: AFC team correct (1/3)
Chiefs over Packers
Result: 0/3
Chiefs over Vikings
Result: Champion correct (2/3)
49ers over Chiefs
Result: Both participants correct (2/3)
That 49ers call ages better every time I think about it. San Francisco entered 2024 as one of the consensus Super Bowl favorites. Predicting them to miss the playoffs entirely was probably the boldest correct prediction in the seven-year sample.
Chiefs over Eagles
Result: Correct matchup, wrong winner (2/3)
49ers over Chiefs
Result: 0/3
| Season | Prediction | Actual | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | Chiefs over Saints | Chiefs over 49ers | ⭐⭐☆☆ (Champion + AFC) |
| 2020 | Chiefs over Saints | Buccaneers over Chiefs | ⭐☆☆☆ (AFC only) |
| 2021 | Chiefs over Packers | Rams over Bengals | ☆☆☆☆ |
| 2022 | Chiefs over Vikings | Chiefs over Eagles | ⭐⭐☆☆ (Champion + AFC) |
| 2023 | 49ers over Chiefs | Chiefs over 49ers | ⭐⭐☆☆ (Both participants) |
| 2024 | Chiefs over Eagles | Eagles over Chiefs | ⭐⭐☆☆ (Both participants) |
| 2025 | 49ers over Chiefs | Seahawks over Patriots | ☆☆☆☆ |
Total: 9 of 21 possible "hits."
That's actually a pretty solid run. Four of seven seasons correctly identified two of the three Super Bowl elements.
After seven seasons, I'd say the record is better than average, especially because the author is willing to make predictions that depart from consensus rather than simply echoing preseason rankings. The strongest pattern is identifying stable contenders and correctly forecasting many division favorites. The weaker pattern is occasionally missing rapid breakouts from young quarterbacks or teams (2021 Bengals, 2023 Texans, 2024 Commanders) and sometimes leaning too heavily on the "Super Bowl hangover" heuristic.
| Season | Grade | One-line Summary |
|---|---|---|
| 2019 | A- | Correct Super Bowl champion, perfect AFC East & AFC North. |
| 2020 | B+ | Strong division predictions, missed badly on Texans and NFC East. |
| 2021 | B | Three perfect NFC divisions, but completely whiffed on the Bengals and Super Bowl. |
| 2022 | B+ | Perfect AFC West, picked Chiefs to win the Super Bowl. |
| 2023 | B | Correct Super Bowl matchup, but several major AFC misses (Texans, Ravens, Chargers). |
| 2024 | A | Best preview so far: predicted Chiefs–Eagles Super Bowl, 49ers to miss playoffs, several other excellent contrarian calls. |
| 2025 | C+ | Good division reads in places, but missed on Patriots, Panthers, and the Super Bowl. |
I'd also point out a few trends that emerged over these seven years:
Strengths
Weaknesses