Showing posts with label dst. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dst. Show all posts
Thursday, November 08, 2012
Daylight Saving visually
The red lines mark my approximate waking hours.
The orange lines mark my approximate commute.
Year-round, my morning commute is never in the dark. Yet because we just went off DST, my evening commute in the winter is in the dark.
As for waking hours, in the morning I'm never outside so it doesn't affect me. But during the evenings, I enjoy the long summer days. I would like if the days went longer in the winter too.
To sum up, I like daylight saving time. So much so, that I wish it went year-round, which is the same effect as just shifting all time zones by one hour.
Wednesday, May 02, 2007
Timely Questions
1. Why don't we have Daylight Savings year-round?
I'd say it's a toss up, but personally, I don't think it's worth the switch off of DST, just to move it up. That would in effect make the East Coast UTC-4 all year, and Central UTC-5...etc.
2. What would happen if the continental U.S. had only one time zone, instead of four?
QUESTION #1
Using rough data for Greenwich, England, here's what daylight would look like:
WITHOUT DST:
Winter 8am - 4pm
Summer 4am - 8pm
Winter 8am - 4pm
Summer 4am - 8pm
WITH DST:
Winter 9am - 5pm
Summer 5am - 9pm
Winter 9am - 5pm
Summer 5am - 9pm
In italics, is the current system, no DST in the winter, DST in the summer. In summer it makes sense because losing the hour of daylight from 4am to 5pm is small potatoes, compared to gaining a valuable hour of daylight from 8pm to 9pm.
In the winter though, would we rather have daylight from 8am to 9am, when people are driving to work, or from 4pm to 5pm, when people are driving home?
I'd say it's a toss up, but personally, I don't think it's worth the switch off of DST, just to move it up. That would in effect make the East Coast UTC-4 all year, and Central UTC-5...etc.
QUESTION #2
Are time zones worth it?
Let's look at the possibilities for the new American Standard Time (AST).
Here's the best case scenario:
National Time of UTC-6 on December 1st
New York: 6am - 3:30pm
Chicago: 7am - 4:20pm
LA: 8:40am - 6:45pm
National Time of UTC-5 on June 1st
New York: 4:30am - 7:20pm
Chicago: 5:30am - 8:20pm
LA: 7:43am - 10pm
National Time of UTC-6 on December 1st
New York: 6am - 3:30pm
Chicago: 7am - 4:20pm
LA: 8:40am - 6:45pm
National Time of UTC-5 on June 1st
New York: 4:30am - 7:20pm
Chicago: 5:30am - 8:20pm
LA: 7:43am - 10pm
Here's the deal with time zones: sunrises and sunsets are local events. But other events: sports, TV shows, everything else really, is happening at the same instant, no matter where you are.
Does it makes sense to say that a basketball game is tipping off at 7:15 in New York, and only 6:15 in Chicago? No.
It's not worth it for the business confusion, flight times, and everything else.
Ironically, this was the best case scenario for summer and winter nationally, and this happens to be central time with daylight savings. So Chicago won't have to do anything different.
I think we could either get rid of Daylight Saving Time or get rid of American time zones, but not both.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
