GOAT Quarterbacks

Super Bowl Winning Quarterback by NFL Season

2001: Brady

2002: Johnson

2003: Brady

2004: Brady

2005: Big Ben

2006: Peyton

2007: Eli

2008: Big Ben

2009: Brees

2010: Rodgers

2011: Eli

2012: Flacco

2013: Wilson

2014: Brady

2015: Peyton

2016: Brady

2017: Foles

2018: Brady

2019: Mahomes

2020: Brady

2021: Stafford

2022: Mahomes

2023: Mahomes

7 of the last 10 Super Bowls were won by Brady + Mahomes. 

Here's the list of NFL playoff wins for Starting Quarterbacks

Brady: 35

Montana: 16

Mahomes: 15

Bradshaw/Peyton/Elway: 14

Here's the list of Quarterbacks with 3+ Super Bowl Wins

Only 3 players in NFL history have 2 regular season MVPs and 3 Super Bowl rings:

Joe Montana

Tom Brady

Patrick Mahomes

Only 3 Players in NFL history have 3 Super Bowl MVPs

Joe Montana

Tom Brady

Patrick Mahomes

Joe Montana born 1956

Tom Brady born 1977

Patrick Mahomes born 1995

This is the list of generational quarterbacks.

Here's their career stats, by the way:

I think it's going to be very hard for Mahomes to get to 7. Kelce doesn't have that many seasons left in him. Reid will likely retire in the middle of Mahomes career. There will be some retooling seasons and there's so many good quarterbacks and teams out there. Even if Mahomes gets to 6 or 7, Brady has the head-to-head wins in the playoffs. 

But even getting to this point is the stuff of legends. To come out of the gate and surpass instant Hall of Famer Peyton Manning's career accomplishments in 6 seasons is mind-blowing. Mahomes hasn't even played Rodgers yet and he's already shifted the conversation from "is Mahomes the best in the league" to "is Mahomes top 2 or 3 all-time."