2025 Rare Soda Ratings Update

Sprecher Cream 10+

Sprecher Root Beer 10

Boylan Creme 9.9

Hank's Black Cherry 9.8

IBC Black Cherry 9.7

Cheerwine 9.7

Frostie Vanilla Root Beer 9.5

Abita Vanilla Cream 9.4

Fitz's Black Cherry 9.4

Sprecher Door County Cherry 9.3

Sprecher Cherry Cola 9.2

Boylan Black Cherry 9.1

Hank's Root Beer 9

Green River 9

Frostie Concord Grape 9

Boylan Root Beer 8.9

Boylan Birch Beer 8.8

Hank's Grape 8.6

Dublin Vanilla Cream 8.5

Boylan Ginger Ale 8.4

Sprecher Grape 8.3

Mt Sprecher 8.2

Hank's Mexicola 8.2

Sprecher Black Cherry 8.1

Maine Root Mandarin Orange 7

Henry Weinhard's Vanilla Cream 6.5

Frostie Cherry Limeade 6

Big Red 2.5

I went to KC Soda Co and got 12 bottles. 8 new ones, 4 that I knew I loved.

My ratings above include all ratings that I have to date, so I can refer back to one current list.

- - -

Now it's time to identify best of category, for my top three categories:

Cream Soda: Sprecher

Root Beer: Sprecher

Black Cherry: Hank's

- - -

Still want to try: Dr Sprecher, Sprecher Maple Root Beer, Sprecher Orange Dream, Green River Lime, Sprecher Cherry Soda