Monday, August 27, 2007

how SI ruined their covers

Sports Illustrated covers mean something. Just like getting on the Wheaties box, it's a special honor. And yet, this decade they've done something to diminish that honor.

Take a look at these Michael Jordon covers:

(1997)


(2003)

Or how about these Super Bowl covers:

(1998)

(2007)
Can you tell the difference?

I could do this all day, but here's one more from the Masters:

(2001)

(2004)


The difference is that SI covers used to be something worthy of framing and putting on a wall. But now, even on special historic issues, they clutter them up with worthless banners and windows...You think Colts fans or Peyton himself would want to frame a SI cover with Carlos Delgado peeking over his shoulder. And who cares about the NBA Playoff preview when Lefty finally won a major.

2 comments:

  1. I really liked this post. The "Masterpiece" cover is definitely frame-able.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Agreed, this is good stuff. It seems like magazines in general now feel the need to put 200 headlines on the cover. You have a Table of Contents and I know how to read. Just let me appreciate a clean cover. Idiots. Maybe they're worried people won't be able to find the Table of Contents after 15 pages of ads!

    ReplyDelete